Power tends to Corrupt


Work is done by those who understand what they do not manage and dominated by those who manage what they do not understand.
-- Putt's Law



The American ethos is realistic about human corruptibility. The Constitution codifies a system of checks and balances based on the principle that unconstrained power tends to be abused. Puritan notions and the framers knowledge of history went into the separation of powers that is now considered to be integral to sound governance. Neglect of both the premises and the principle of constraint in corporate management has made business entities into hierarchies of self-serving ambition in an environment of intimidation and counterproductive, networked incompetence. Business has become the domain of an aristocracy. Nearly every working person contends with the resulting dysfunction on a daily basis. Working dangerously is to acknowledge the pervasiveness of bad management while trying to remain employed.

Turn the other cheek and read this blog for perspective. It's cheaper than a psychiatrist.


Showing posts with label the Bad. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the Bad. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Workers Who are "actively" Disengaged

Seven out of 10 workers have “checked out” at work or are “actively disengaged,” according to a recent Gallup survey.  Gallup estimates that workers who are actively disengaged cost the U.S. as much as $550 billion in economic activity yearly.
http://seattletimes.com/html/nationworld/2021217458_gallupworkxml.html

So, what's the problem?  Are seven out of ten workers deadbeats, or is there something wrong at the companies they work for?


Saturday, April 6, 2013

CEO Pay Cut 98 Percent

For something approaching a hundred years J. C. Penney was a familiar name in discount merchandising.  Sam Walton started his career at J. C. Penney.  Quality products at reasonable prices was a theme that kept customers happy.  Penney's didn't stay in business selling Louis Voitton suits or Cuisinart kitchen appliances. A practical guy could call up the local clothier and order several pair of pants with nothing more than his waist and inseam size because he had been buying the same brand since his first job as a manager trainee just out of college.  Dad had ordered pants from the Penney's catalog.

In the new millennium Penney's stores were familiar landmarks in shopping malls from sea to shining sea, but the executives running the empire apparently longed to distinguish themselves from the middle class morality of their customers.  In 2007, the company launched a new website with private and exclusive brands, as developed by Ralph Lauren, across several product lines, including men's, women's, and children's apparel and shoes, intimate apparel, and home funishings. The launch was accompanied by an ad campaign during the 2008 Academy Awards.  This was not your mom's J. C. Penney store anymore... .

J. C. Penny Chic

When Ellen DeGeneres, once long ago a J. C. Penney employee, became the chain's spokesperson in a tour and advertising campaign in Spring 2012, it elicited a backlash from One Million Moms, an arm of the conservative American Family Association.  Who could have imagined!

Who should have known?  Well, some assemblage of the board must have thought, when they hired Ron Johnson who had ridden the crest of the wave at Apple, that this hot-shot CEO would turn things around.  Who could be smarter than this guy?  Johnson was paid 53 million for the first two months of his regime beginning in 2011.

The NY Times noted this week that:

"Since Mr. Johnson arrived in late 2011, J. C. Penney has wrestled with one problem after another. Mr. Johnson did away with discount sales, but revived them when it turned out customers liked sales. He proposed a three-tiered pricing strategy that he abandoned when customers were confused. He revamped the company’s advertising strategy to focus on lifestyle, not prices, but backtracked when it turned out customers wanted the ads to tell them how much items cost."

Couldn't several thousand managers with MBAs and marketing degrees have pushed back against this counterproductive nonsense?  They have evidently, finally.
J. C. Penney Slashes Pay of its Chief
It gets worse: J.C. Penney Ousts Chief of 17 Months


Monday, March 25, 2013

Ilya Pozin says Dismantle the Hierarchy

Ilya Pozin is founder of Ciplex, columnist for Inc, Forbes, and LinkedIn. Inc. Magazine 30-under-30 entrepreneur, Pozin says creating hierarchy is counterproductive.  When people work to please a manager or toward a review, they often lose focus on the purpose of their efforts, not to mention the customers.  Internal company politics begin to trump everything.  Instead of intimidating people with the annual review, Pozin suggests:
  • Create a Team Culture
  • Set Goals
  • Provide Support, Not Escalation
  • Remove Rules, Give Autonomy
  • Lead, Don’t Manage
  • Reap the Benefits of Flattening the Hierarchy
Complete article: Want Your Company to Grow? Fire Your Managers!
And another: Why Your Company Should Dismantle Hierarchies

So much for Jack Welch's seminars!

Monday, October 10, 2011

Occupy Wall Street or the Tea Party?

Sure, I think big business has too much power, and in the attempt to maintain control, boards of directors and bosses give their minions too much power. They want managers who are unquestioningly loyal. They find managers who are controllable, and they give them power to intimidate people.  Nothing works because intimidation is counterproductive.  The stock holders and CEOs don't know enough history to see the similarity of governmental abuse of power to their own abuse of power. Aristocrats by any name do the same damage.

Now we have the worst power mongering in government collaborating with the worst in business. Chris Dodd and Barney Frank were right in the middle of the fight over stimulus and collapse in the mortgage market.  The worst accusations of both liberals and conservatives are evidently correct. Big business and big government are on our backs, and the only end in sight is the looming debt collapse.

Coming from opposite sides of the controversy, Niall Ferguson and Angelo Codevilla are both correct. Ferguson is a Harvard economist and Codavilla is a conservative historian who has published in the American Spectator.  Here are links to both of their works: http://working-dangerously.blogspot.com/2011/05/niall-ferguson-angelo-codevilla.html

When the checks from Washington DC bounce, maybe control will devolve back to the states.   Without big government preventing real competition between business entities, some tolerable balance of power could result.

Saturday, September 24, 2011

Destroying a Bank's Legacy of Success

Washington Mutual survived the Great Depression and a crisis that wiped out a quarter of all U.S. thrifts in the 1990s. It became a national brand.  With such endurance, how is it possible this once stalwart institution ended up as the largest bank failure in American history? Within the answer to that question are important lessons for leaders about building and maintaining successful organizations.

This spectacular collapse has been reported to be the result of extraordinary loan losses followed by a massive run on deposits. What really killed WaMu, however, was a change in the company's century-old culture and values — a misguided move that marginalized its historic regard and care for employees and customers in the interest of driving an ever-expanding bottom line for shareholders.

In 2006, the bank experienced an extraordinary 50 percent turnover in its key customer-facing positions. Customer complaints soared.

A senior-level employee-relations manager said, "Employees rarely depart for more money. They leave because they believe the company they work for has lost its heart." In confirmation, exiting workers routinely told Human Resources, "My manager doesn't care, you don't care and the company doesn't care."

Washington Mutual was in no way unique in choosing to rip the heart out of its culture. The bank is just another example of how we collectively seek to motivate human performance in the American workplace.  According to a 22-year ongoing study, 55 percent of all American workers hate their jobs. They've made it very clear that all they want is to feel valued, appreciated and cared for — to work for a company they respect and to feel their contributions matter.

Story in Seattle Times by Mark Crowley: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/opinion/2016301121_guest25crowley.html

Monday, September 12, 2011

Corporations paying CEOs more than they pay in taxes

The Institute for Policy Studies released a report Wednesday that shows many large companies pay more to CEOs in compensation than they did in corporate income taxes to the federal government in 2010.

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Business is not Baseball

Jack Welch says the key to success in business is setting clear goals and differentiating among the divisions of a company and its employees on the basis of performance in relation to the goals.  On this view, a well functioning company works like a servo mechanism that adjusts clockwise or counter clockwise based on feedback that determines its position in relation to center.  When Jack Welch was CEO of General Electric, he determined that being number 1 or number 2 in its field would define the framework for success for every division of the company.  Each had to achieve the goal, or be fixed. Otherwise it was eliminated.  When you start reading Jack's magnum opus, Winning, you assume Jack is pretty soon going to tell you what he means by number 1 or number 2, but a few pages later he says he "has always disliked financial measurements".  If number 1 or 2 is not defined by a financial metric, what does it mean to be number 1 or number 2?  So far in the book, I've found no explanation.  I suppose he means market share.

But, having defined differentiation among business divisions as being number 1 or number 2, Jack moves on to differentiation among employees.  Lavishly rewarding the top 20%, encouraging and training the middle 70%, and eliminating the lowest 10%, he says are not cruel or Darwinian in business but, rather, fair and effective.  Jack is unequivocal on the metrics of the review process that determines the winners and losers in this methodology.  He learned how differentiation operates when he was kid playing baseball: the kids were lined up and the best players were chosen first, the mediocre players next, and last, if at all, the poor players, who were left to sit on the bench or find something they were better suited to do.  On this he seems to be quite right. Many of those poor ball players spent their time studying math or biology, eventually becoming engineers and doctors. 

Baseball is a game in which the score is a clear measure of a team's success.  Business, in any rational analysis, depends on a financial measure of profitability and on intelligent management of employees with the diverse skills required to compete in an advanced technical economy.  It doesn't take much intelligence to understand that those skills are more diverse and technical than the skills required by baseball players.  Jack appears to be saying that performance reviews in business amount to the same thing as children choosing players for their teams on the ball field.  He uses a similar analogy from pro baseball early in his book.  Somewhere in this decisive managerial perspective there seems to be an explanation for the cynicism among engineering and pre-med students that the business school is for people who don't have the grit to study math, physics, or biology. 

Saturday, July 30, 2011

Red States, Including the ‘Newly-Reds,’ Excel at Job Growth

Now that state employment information for the first half of 2011 is available, one can’t help but notice which states are up, as well as a particularly telling example of one that is down. Though admittedly the comparison isn’t apples to apples, it’s worth noting that of the 757,000 seasonally adjusted jobs added in the overall economy this year from January through June, the ten states with the highest percentage employment growth were responsible for well over half, or 390,000 of them, even though they only have about 20% of the nation’s population.

http://pajamasmedia.com/blog/data-show-majority-of-job-gains-in-red-states/