Power tends to Corrupt


Work is done by those who understand what they do not manage and dominated by those who manage what they do not understand.
-- Putt's Law



The American ethos is realistic about human corruptibility. The Constitution codifies a system of checks and balances based on the principle that unconstrained power tends to be abused. Puritan notions and the framers knowledge of history went into the separation of powers that is now considered to be integral to sound governance. Neglect of both the premises and the principle of constraint in corporate management has made business entities into hierarchies of self-serving ambition in an environment of intimidation and counterproductive, networked incompetence. Business has become the domain of an aristocracy. Nearly every working person contends with the resulting dysfunction on a daily basis. Working dangerously is to acknowledge the pervasiveness of bad management while trying to remain employed.

Turn the other cheek and read this blog for perspective. It's cheaper than a psychiatrist.


Monday, August 29, 2011

The Myth of Managerial Planning

During one of the semi-annual ordeals Microsoft management inflicts on workers, called planning and commitments, a coworker, a Russian woman who was educated in schools administered by Soviet Socialists, commented on the similarity of managerial planning at Microsoft to planning by the Soviet centralized committees that are now discredited everywhere except possibly in the the bankrupt state of California.

"They were always coming up with 'The Five Year Plan' or some such thing," she said, and among her family and friends, who are also Russian employees at Microsoft, the discussion had evidently echoed this weird sensation they were having of being transported back to the oppressive culture they thought they had escaped.

I've heard similar sentiments from Romanians who worked for the Communists during the early years of their careers.  They say things were often so bad that they would sabotage projects to retaliate against ignorant bosses.  Sabotage was the only form of defiance possible under the circumstances.  This, again, has parallels in American industry.  It is not surprising to read stories about organized union sabotage behind callbacks by auto manufacturers to repair components that are failing on a massive scale.

During every planning cycle at Microsoft, somebody asks, "Why do we do this?"  No work gets done for several weeks, and before the plans get through review, they are already useless, or nearly so, except in managerial meetings; there the absurdities go on pretty much continuously.  Of course, in the perspective of working dangerously, this is getting pretty close to an explanation.

Microsoft management has adopted many of the principles that Jack Welch promulgates in his books, which viewed from a certain perspective are brilliant but result in cerebral contusions when abstractions crash against concrete reality.  Not surprisingly an example of the myth of managerial planning can be found in Jack's best seller Winning.  The former CEO of General Electric, whose accomplishments the dust jacket of the book advertises as if Jack were campaigning for something, is discussing What Winners are Made Of.  Not English syntax, evidently.

Winners, good managers in this perspective, are made of positive energy, the ability to energize others, the ability to make tough decisions, otherwise known as edge, and then we read an absolutely astonishing story about how Jack and his HR director Bill Conaty discover the fourth essential constituent of managerial ability.  Jack and Bill are flying back to headquarters during a search for promotable executives, and looking over "page after page of high-potentials with three solidly colored-in circles".  (Yes, the CEO and HR director of General Electric like coloring books.)  The three circles of their promotable, high-potential managers represent positive energy, ability to energize others, and edge, but, I'm not making this up, the HR director turns to the CEO and says, "You know, Jack, we're missing something.  We have all these great people, but some of their results stink."  The next paragraph is a single sentence: "What was missing was execution."

In this dumbfounding testimonial to inane deliberations by exalted managers there is an argument for the elimination of schools of business administration everywhere.  How Jack could work for thirty years in business and become the CEO of any profitable enterprise, much less General Electric, without apprehension of the fact that executives have to deliver tangible results, or something, to verify that they can execute on all the fire in the belly they evince during planning meetings, is almost unbelievable.  It is almost unbelievable, but not unbelievable for workers who daily have to endure the dysfunctional processes overseen by their managers, who annually suffer through reviews based on career-stage profiles and assessments of their performance by people with MBAs instead of computer science degrees, and all the other inanities of managers who spend four days of every week in planning meetings but never go into a lab. 

How did hard-nosed business people ever go so soft in the head?  What happened to the simple objectifying principle that you can't manage what you can't measure?  Somebody with money that can be wasted indefinitely, without exhausting the spendthrifts or emptying their expense accounts, has vested so much power in managers that they don't have to listen to feedback from engineers or the sales staff.  It seems that some of them do listen and go to the lab, or nothing would get done right.   But, like mega-managing Communists, managers have too much power over too many human resources.  They can't manage effectively, or they don't have any compelling motivation to manage effectively, such as a CEO who knows that execution is what counts.  The heading of this blog bluntly asserts that the problem with American business is that managers have too much power.  Historically, the human race is supposed to have learned that power corrupts when it rejected taxation without representation and the divine right of kings. American business is in a time-warp that is some analogue of feudalism.

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Business is not Baseball

Jack Welch says the key to success in business is setting clear goals and differentiating among the divisions of a company and its employees on the basis of performance in relation to the goals.  On this view, a well functioning company works like a servo mechanism that adjusts clockwise or counter clockwise based on feedback that determines its position in relation to center.  When Jack Welch was CEO of General Electric, he determined that being number 1 or number 2 in its field would define the framework for success for every division of the company.  Each had to achieve the goal, or be fixed. Otherwise it was eliminated.  When you start reading Jack's magnum opus, Winning, you assume Jack is pretty soon going to tell you what he means by number 1 or number 2, but a few pages later he says he "has always disliked financial measurements".  If number 1 or 2 is not defined by a financial metric, what does it mean to be number 1 or number 2?  So far in the book, I've found no explanation.  I suppose he means market share.

But, having defined differentiation among business divisions as being number 1 or number 2, Jack moves on to differentiation among employees.  Lavishly rewarding the top 20%, encouraging and training the middle 70%, and eliminating the lowest 10%, he says are not cruel or Darwinian in business but, rather, fair and effective.  Jack is unequivocal on the metrics of the review process that determines the winners and losers in this methodology.  He learned how differentiation operates when he was kid playing baseball: the kids were lined up and the best players were chosen first, the mediocre players next, and last, if at all, the poor players, who were left to sit on the bench or find something they were better suited to do.  On this he seems to be quite right. Many of those poor ball players spent their time studying math or biology, eventually becoming engineers and doctors. 

Baseball is a game in which the score is a clear measure of a team's success.  Business, in any rational analysis, depends on a financial measure of profitability and on intelligent management of employees with the diverse skills required to compete in an advanced technical economy.  It doesn't take much intelligence to understand that those skills are more diverse and technical than the skills required by baseball players.  Jack appears to be saying that performance reviews in business amount to the same thing as children choosing players for their teams on the ball field.  He uses a similar analogy from pro baseball early in his book.  Somewhere in this decisive managerial perspective there seems to be an explanation for the cynicism among engineering and pre-med students that the business school is for people who don't have the grit to study math, physics, or biology. 

Monday, August 22, 2011

We've been warned: the system is ready to blow

Only a new way of managing the global economy can prevent more mayhem in the markets and on the streets.

For the past two centuries and more, life in Britain has been governed by a simple concept: tomorrow will be better than today. Black August has given us a glimpse of a dystopia, one in which the financial markets buckle and the cities burn. Like Scrooge, we have been shown what might be to come unless we change our ways.

There were glimmers of hope amid last week's despair. Neighbourhoods rallied round in the face of the looting. The Muslim community in Birmingham showed incredible dignity after three young men were mown down by a car and killed during the riots. It was chastening to see consumerism laid bare. We have seen the future and we know it sucks. All of which is cause for cautious optimism – provided the right lessons are drawn.

Lesson number one is that the financial and social causes are linked. Lesson number two is that what links the City banker and the looter is the lack of restraint, the absence of boundaries to bad behaviour. Lesson number three is that we ignore this at our peril.

Guardian News UK: http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/aug/14/larry-elliott-global-financial-system

A new film about corporate layoffs

The Company Men
Even hot shots get it in the teeth and have to hype themselves into action, looking for work:
http://d.yimg.com/nl/movies/site/player.html#shareUrl=http%3A%2F%2Fmovies.yahoo.com%2Fmovie%2F1810079612%2Fvideo%2F20986858&vid=20986858



Sunday, August 14, 2011

The Gulf Oil Spill: A Classic Failure of Systems Leadership

This one from Harvard Business Review.
As systems become more complex, the likelihood of systems failures becomes ever greater. Absent a fundamental rethinking of how we define and enforce accountability, we should have absolutely no confidence that leaders in the private and public sectors will take responsibility when things hit the fan.
http://blogs.hbr.org/watkins/2010/05/the_gulf_oil_spill_a_classic_f.html

Thursday, August 11, 2011

Objection to Management Decisions...

Objection to management decisions is undesirable when you are wrong and unforgivable when you are right.
-- Archibald Putt

Originator of Putt's Law: Those who understand technology do not manage, and those who manage do not understand.  And the corollary: Every technical hierarchy over time develops a competence inversion.

An audio interview with the author is available at IT Conversations
http://itc.conversationsnetwork.org/shows/detail1698.html#

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

The Devil is in the Documentation

A friend who had a long successful career as an executive at Swiss Air told me it was conventional wisdom that an exec should never put anything in writing. I found out why when I began my career as a technical writer.
 
Writing documentation that isn’t just puff requires operational knowledge of the product.  Too often, the product doesn’t work as the specification indicates that it should work, so writers find problems that some stakeholders don’t want anybody to find until after their reviews are completed and they have moved to a new project.

Stakeholders do not even want to review documentation because, if they do, they must approve it or correct mistakes, and if something gets past them that is wrong, they can be held accountable. Publishing documentation is a commitment that many fear because there are changes planned or already implemented that will break the advertised features of the product and things will not perform as expected.
 
Am I being too cynical?. Why should I worry about meetings to which I won’t be invited, in which the project managers will say the problems customers are having are simply the result of bad documentation… .

Theodore Dalrymple on British Rioting

The ferocious criminality exhibited by an uncomfortably large section of the English population during the current riots has not surprised me in the least. I have been writing about it, in its slightly less acute manifestations, for the past 20 years. To have spotted it required no great perspicacity on my part; rather, it took a peculiar cowardly blindness, one regularly displayed by the British intelligentsia and political class, not to see it and not to realize its significance. There is nothing that an intellectual less likes to change than his mind, or a politician his policy.
http://www.city-journal.org/2011/eon0810td.html?utm_medium=twitter&utm_source=twitterfeed

The riots are the apotheosis of the welfare state and popular culture in their British form. A population thinks (because it has often been told so by intellectuals and the political class) that it is entitled to a high standard of consumption, irrespective of its personal efforts; and therefore it regards the fact that it does not receive that high standard, by comparison with the rest of society, as a sign of injustice. It believes itself deprived (because it has often been told so by intellectuals and the political class), even though each member of it has received an education costing $80,000, toward which neither he nor—quite likely—any member of his family has made much of a contribution; indeed, he may well have lived his entire life at others’ expense, such that every mouthful of food he has ever eaten, every shirt he has ever worn, every television he has ever watched, has been provided by others. Even if he were to recognize this, he would not be grateful, for dependency does not promote gratitude. On the contrary, he would simply feel that the subventions were not sufficient to allow him to live as he would have liked.

At the same time, his expensive education will have equipped him for nothing. His labor, even supposing that he were inclined to work, would not be worth its cost to any employer—partly because of the social charges necessary to keep others such as he in a state of permanent idleness, and partly because of his own characteristics. And so unskilled labor is performed in England by foreigners, while an indigenous class of permanently unemployed is subsidized.

Theodore Dalrymple, a physician, is a contributing editor of City Journal and the Dietrich Weismann Fellow at the Manhattan Institute.  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_Dalrymple

Monday, August 8, 2011

Putt's Law

Technology is dominated by two types of people: those who understand what they do not manage, and those who manage what they do not understand.

Organizations over time tend to develop a competency inversion.

An audio interview with the originator of this maxim is available at IT Conversations:
http://itc.conversationsnetwork.org/shows/detail1698.html

Wednesday, August 3, 2011

Hi ho, hi ho, we owe.

Pretty interesting read from Alec Baldwin at the Huffing and Puffing Post: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/alec-baldwin/its-time-to-suck-it-up-an_b_913810.html

How long did you think this could last? How much longer did you think a cadre of fully compromised, ethically bankrupt public officials would allow you to play in traffic before you got hit by the Reality Bus?

We... owe... the money. We elected incompetent fools/rapacious petrogarchs to high office. We gave them a credit card. They maxed it out. They got several more and maxed those out, too. And we are the co-signers.

Raise the debt ceiling, like every president has bitten the bullet and done. Raise taxes and take your medicine. You cared, innocently, about helping others. No shame in that. But simultaneously, you got married to a couple of idiots who blew all your money and left the whole family with nothing to show for it. Saddam's dead? Osama's dead? Is that gonna help you get a job? Pay your rent? Buy your kid some sneakers for school this fall?

Wake up. We gotta suck it up. Pay this bill. And have a loooooong talk about how we never get here again, while still maintaining our identity as a great country made up of great, caring people.