Fifteen years in the Microsoft corporate culture have given me time to
contemplate the workings of envy and scapegoating, not in literature, but among
people with computer science degrees, MBAs, and the various skills of a throng
of nerdy techies. I was in my forties when I started working in technology and
had not invested as many years in school or at the computer as most of my
multi-national coworkers. I was not disposed to endure everything I encountered
without questioning the rationale or the authority behind it. In the first few
days of my employment, I was struck by the fear and intimidation evident among
people who were driving new cars and enjoying the satisfactions of Microsoft's
success, which was everywhere apparent on the corporate campus. This was 1997
and Microsoft stock was soaring. These people were doing very well, but an
expression that I heard too often was, "A chain is only as strong as its
weakest link".
When my employment was terminated after nine days, I was stunned. The boss,
a cordial Brazilian, said I was a smart guy--he and several others had
interviewed me, tested my coding skills, and hired me. He said he'd finesse the
record so this would not prevent me from getting another job, which I did, but
it was not without feeling homicidal toward several people who had evaluated me
as inadequate in their private conversations and made it clear to management
that I was a weak link. More unsettling was the disdain of a woman I met at a party, whom I considered a friend, whose only snarky comment was,
"You don't work at Microsoft anymore!" By then I had another job and
could deflect her by saying so, but, in her eyes I had sunk beneath contempt.
Astonishing! My dismissal wasn't on the evening news. Who cared enough to talk
about it?
This was the first time that I encountered or witnessed this variety of
predatory paranoia that still gives me pause. I had not read René Girard, but I
remember a conversation with a manager whose authority over more than a hundred
people didn't insulate him. A lawyer, a former district attorney, for some
reason he had changed careers and written a couple of books on technology. He
had been successful at Microsoft, but he volunteered his bewilderment at the
degree of treachery in the company. "I don't understand it!" He said.
"What makes them go looking for somebody to hang?" After a time, he
found that even he was not safe. A woman a level above him in the hierarchy
found reason to work the system against him. He landed on his feet and ended up
working at a high level in HR. Now, after a look at the address book, I see
that even he is gone.
I had been thinking about this for a long time before I read René Girard or
it occurred to me that his ideas could explain the Microsoft culture. My own
view is that in a very competitive environment, people who are used to being
high in any ranking of skills or status will get edgy when they face serious
competition. A corporation with the capital reserves to hire experts in any
imaginable technology will pit habitual achievers against others who know more
than they do about something. And, quite a number of habitually successful people
are overachievers. It is inevitable that they will sooner or later find
themselves out of their depth, and likely, embarrassed in one situation or
another by what they don't know, even while they are making more money than
they aspired to make only a few years ago. This can lead to a situation in
which many of them feel that some of what they have achieved and acquired,
deservedly or not, could be taken away from them. In this state of mind one
rational response is what is politely called networking, otherwise known as
politics. This might explain the closing of ranks against some workers. It
doesn't necessarily follow that the network benefits by humiliating or
rejecting the supposed under performer. After all, the anxiety that drives some
workers to network is evidence that they are under performing. They know that
in some sense they can't make it on their own.
René Girard proposes that it is not anxiety about the loss of property or
privilege that drives people to victimize others. His hypothesis is that
predatory competition is motivated by mimetic envy. In this view,
people are so unenlightened about their self-interest, clueless about what
they, in fact, want and need, that they copy the desires of others. The desires
are essentially covetous. The result of mimetic envy is relentless competition.
People want the same things that, usually, it is impossible for all to attain.
This is certainly the case when they all want to come out of the annual
review as top performers. Scapegoating provides a release of the
psychological compression. The pathos of the scapegoat is an analog of the fate
that is feared by those in the network who drive him into the wilderness. For a
while it calms them, and they can go about their business without fear.
Power tends to Corrupt
Work is done by those who understand what they do not manage and dominated by those who manage what they do not understand.
-- Putt's Law
The American ethos is realistic about human corruptibility. The Constitution codifies a system of checks and balances based on the principle that unconstrained power tends to be abused. Puritan notions and the framers knowledge of history went into the separation of powers that is now considered to be integral to sound governance. Neglect of both the premises and the principle of constraint in corporate management has made business entities into hierarchies of self-serving ambition in an environment of intimidation and counterproductive, networked incompetence. Business has become the domain of an aristocracy. Nearly every working person contends with the resulting dysfunction on a daily basis. Working dangerously is to acknowledge the pervasiveness of bad management while trying to remain employed.
Turn the other cheek and read this blog for perspective. It's cheaper than a psychiatrist.